Opinion: If We Split Illinois Into Two States ... - NBC Chicago
Ward Room
Covering Chicago's nine political influencers

Opinion: If We Split Illinois Into Two States ...



    Another Downstate politician is agitating to kick Chicago out of Illinois. Last year, Bill Mitchell, a Republican from Forsyth, suggested we form our own state. This time, it’s a Democrat.

    State Sen. Gary Forby of Benton is furious that Gov. Pat Quinn wants to close the super-maximum security in Tamms, which lies in his deep Southern Illinois district. On Thursday, Forby went off -- not just on Quinn, but on our entire city.

    “I’ve been hearing it for a long time, but why don’t we do away with Chicago?” Forby ranted. “You know, I’m just about there. I’m about ready to just cut ’em off and push ’em right out in the water. ... Put him [the governor] right on the nose of the boat and push him right out in the water.”

    Downstate’s contempt for Chicago is now officially bi-partisan. So what would happen if Illinois split into two states?

    Let’s suppose the six northeastern counties -- Cook, DuPage, Lake, Kane, Will and McHenry -- were split off from the rest of the state. They could keep the name, since the Illinois Indians didn’t live up here. We’d call our new state Potawatomi.

        Potawatomi: 8.3 million
        Illinois: 4.5 million

        Fortune 500 companies
        Potawatomi: 28
        Illinois: 4 (Archer Daniels Midland, State Farm, Caterpillar, Deere)

        State universities
        Potawatomi: 4
        Illinois: 8

        Potawatomi: 1
        Illinois: 40

        State Parks
        Potawatomi: 6
        Illinois: 35

        Per capita income
        Potawatomi: Ranges from $23,227 in Cook County to $35,546 in DuPage County
        Illinois: Ranges from $13,325 in Pulaski County to $23,173 in Sangamon County.

    Downstaters who want to separate from Chicago assume they’ll be able to establish a conservative paradise of loose gun laws, speedy executions, intolerance of homosexuals and low taxes. Certainly an Illinois General Assembly purged of Cook County legislators would allow concealed carry of handguns, reinstate the death penalty, and ban civil unions for gays and lesbians.

    But as the above chart demonstrates, Potawatomi has most of the population and most of the money, while Illinois has most of the publicly-funded institutions. If a rump Illinois wanted to maintain its system of universities, state parks and prisons, it would have to raise income taxes beyond their current 5 percent. It could decide to close some institutions, and probably would, since a smaller population would not require so many parks, prisons and colleges. But doing so would eliminate the jobs of thousands of professionals, who would leave Illinois in droves, thus depriving the state of a middle class.

    There may have been a time when it was practical to split Illinois in two, but that time was around 1850. 

    Buy this book! Ward Room blogger Edward McClelland's book, Young Mr. Obama: Chicago and the Making of a Black President , is available Amazon. Young Mr. Obama includes reporting on President Obama's earliest days in the Windy City, covering how a presumptuous young man transformed himself into presidential material. Buy it now!