Cutler chowed down on the Southside Slugger (1/2 lb fresh ground Black Angus burger with smoked ham, angry onions, cheddar & finished with a fried egg) and a Stella. Cavallari ordered the Rookie with cheddar cheese (another version of the Angus burger with shaved red onions) and a Blue Moon.
Our spies tell us that the pair kept the PDA to a minimum, but Cutler did have his arm around her several times during dinner. However, the real love affair was between Cavallari and her order of truffle fries, which she kept talking about all night.
The duo left a hefty tip before leaving together in a cab.