Justice Scalia Says Chicago Pie isn't 'Real Pizza'

"It should be called a tomato pie," the U.S. Supreme Court Justice said at Chicago-Kent Law School

View Comments ()




    New York thin-crust versus Chicago's deep-dish: It's a historic battle between the Big Apple and the Windy City.

    U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia picked his preferred pie Tuesday during a Chicago conference at Chicago-Kent School of Law, "ruling" that deep-dish isn't pizza at all.

    FeastTV: Pizza on the Grill

    [CHI] FeastTV: Pizza on the Grill
    The owner of "The Chopping Block" shows off just one recipe taught in their outdoor grilling classes. (Published Wednesday, June 2, 2010)

    Scalia was in town for a student conference discussing the issue of the government's role in confiscating private property, according to the Chicago Sun-Times. But his comments didn't stop there.

    "I do indeed like so-called 'deep dish pizza.' It's very tasty," Scalia said. "But it should not be called pizza. It should be called a tomato pie. Real pizza is Neapolitan. It is thin. It is chewy and crispy, OK?"

    Making Pizza With Bricks Pizza

    [CHI] Making Pizza With Bricks Pizza

    This isn't the first time Scalia has issued his opinion on the two types of 'za. In a January interview with California Lawyer Magazine, he discussed which pizza he liked best.

    "You know these deep-dish pizzas - it's not pizza," Scalia told the publication. "It's very good, but ... call it tomato pie or something ... I'm a traditionalist, what can I tell you?

    Chicagoans were not happy to hear his opinion on the city's baseball teams either, the Associated Press points out.

    When asked "White Sox or Cubs?" Scalia said he was a Yankees fan, drawing boos from the audience.