coronavirus

Cook County ME Could Review Deaths as Far Back as September if More COVID Cases Found

"If we see some cases from November, we could go further backward, maybe September," said Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Ponni Arunkumar

NBCUniversal, Inc.

The Cook County Medical Examiner's office could review deaths from as far back as September if it finds additional COVID-19 fatalities during its current analysis.

Currently, the medical examiner is conducting a review of deaths dating back to November of last year to see if any previously recorded deaths may have been related to the coronavirus before health officials publicly identified widespread community transmission.

County officials say the review will specifically look at people who died of pneumonia to see if the case was viral, and heart attacks to check for signs of thrombosis, or blood clots - both of which have been found in people with COVID-19.

The office is also looking at cases that had flu-like symptoms at the time of death.

The review has found at least 30 such cases so far and is working to determine if any of them could be related to COVID-19.

"If we see some cases from November, we could go further backward, maybe September," said Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Ponni Arunkumar.

The review will include a look back at cases of people who died in their homes or were found on the street, or other instances in which the person's death fell under the jurisdiction of the county, Cook County spokeswoman Natalia Derevyanny said previously. It will not include people who died in hospitals, she said, because doctors sign the death certificates of patients who die while hospitalized and the county is not notified.

"The Cook County Medical Examiner’s Office is conducting this review because we believe this information is important in understanding the true impact COVID-19 has had on our community from an epidemiological and public health standpoint and also to help us fully understand how this virus has spread," Derevyanny said in a statement.

Derevyanny said roughly 40,000 people die each year in Cook County, with around 6,000 of those cases ending up under the medical examiner's jurisdiction.

Gov. J.B. Pritzker has now revealed details on a five-phased plan to reopen Illinois as the state remains under a stay-at-home order through May 30.

Cook County officials did not receive a directive from the state to conduct the review, Derevyanny added - though Gov. J.B. Pritzker said last week that he believes such a review would likely be necessary around the state.

Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention released on April 28 suggested that between March 8 and April 11, there were an additional 700 deaths above average in Illinois that were not attributed to COVID-19.

When asked about the CDC's findings, Pritzker said in his daily briefing the following day that he agreed it could be possible people in Illinois were contracting and dying from the coronavirus well before the outbreak was widely documented, and that the spike may have been previously unreported coronavirus fatalities that health officials would need to re-examine at some point.

"I think everybody's realizing, indeed, there's been a recent report out of California… that shows that people had COVID-19 long before anybody thought here in the United States. And so it's probably true here in Illinois that people had coronavirus long before," he said.

An autopsy report released last month revealed that tissue samples from two people who died in their homes in Santa Clara County, California, on Feb. 6 and Feb. 17 tested positive for the coronavirus.

Prior to the release of that report, the first U.S. death from the virus had been reported on Feb. 29 in Kirkland, Washington - meaning the first COVID-19 death in the country happened weeks earlier than previously thought.

Santa Clara County health officials said the deaths were not initially attributed to the coronavirus because the victims died at home at a time when limited testing for the virus was available - a thought Pritzker echoed last week.

"Some of the deaths that nobody was even talking about, they didn't have a name for this thing," he said. "People were dying and they may have been put on their death certificate they died of pneumonia or some other respiratory illness."

"So there's no doubt that we're going to need to go back through the records," Pritzker continued, adding, "That's going to probably happen in months hence, because we have so much to do now to focus on keeping people safe and alive now, but we're probably going to have to go back and see you know, how many of these probably, based upon all the symptoms, were COVID-19?"

Dr. Emily Landon is the chief infectious disease epidemiologist at the University of Chicago Medicine, who moments after Pritzker issued the ordinance to take effect Saturday evening, took to the stand with a 7-minute-long speech that went viral after striking a chord for many individuals.

Pritzker's comments came days after Illinois Department of Public Health Director Dr. Ngozi Ezike expressed a similar sentiment. Ezike said on April 24 that it was "very likely" that cases of coronavirus were present in Illinois before the state's first diagnosis, adding that officials would update records to include any deaths later categorized as those caused by COVID-19.

"When our first case was identified, it was the second case in the U.S. Of course, it begs the question," Ezike said during Pritzker's daily briefing. "That individual was not on a flight that came in after any travel restrictions and screenings were in place. So for sure, if we think that this virus originated in Wuhan and people were traveling to the U.S., it is possible, very likely that cases, individuals who had this, had come before our first diagnosed cases."

"So potentially there have been other illnesses that were not appreciated," she continued. "And I know that maybe there'll be requests by families, maybe medical examiners will be reviewing some of their records. We wouldn't stop any of that. If they identify new cases, we will have to adjust our case counts and we will absolutely do that to update our data."

Contact Us