New York may have undercounted COVID-19 deaths among nursing home residents by thousands, the state attorney general charged in a report Thursday that dealt a blow to Gov. Andrew Cuomo's oft-repeated claims that his state is doing better than others in protecting its most vulnerable.
The 76-page report found an undercount of more than 50%, backing up the findings of an Associated Press investigation last year that focused on the fact that New York is one of the only states in the nation that count residents who died on nursing home property and not those who later died in hospitals.
Such an undercount would mean the state's current official tally of 8,711 nursing home deaths to the virus is actually more than 13,000, boosting New York from No. 6 to highest in the nation.
“While we cannot bring back the individuals we lost to this crisis, this report seeks to offer transparency that the public deserves,” Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement.
The report from a fellow Democratic official undercut Cuomo's frequent argument that the criticism of his handling of the virus in nursing homes was part of a political “blame game," and it was a vindication for thousands of families who believed their loved ones were being omitted from counts to advance the governor's image as a pandemic hero.
“It’s important to me that my mom was counted,” said Vivian Zayas, whose 78-year-old mother died in April after contracting COVID-19 at a nursing home in West Islip, New York. “Families like mine knew these numbers were not correct.”
Full coverage of the COVID-19 outbreak and how it impacts you
In a lengthy statement contesting the findings of the report, New York State Health Commissioner Howard Zucker said that the department "has always publicly reported the number of fatalities within hospitals irrespective of the residence of the patient, and separately reported the number of fatalities within nursing home facilities and has been clear about the nature of that reporting." He also said that the report confirms the state's total number of deaths is accurate, and was only referring to nursing home residents who were transferred to hospitals and later died.
"The word 'undercount' implies there are more total fatalities than have been reported; that is factually wrong," Zucker said in the statement. "In fact, the OAG report itself repudiates the suggestion that there was any 'undercount' of the total death number."
In short, Zucker said that the only discrepancy exists in assigning the number of deaths in hospitals versus nursing homes, but the total number of deaths is not being disputed.
Cuomo, at his regular Friday news conference, blamed the entire investigation on a politically motivated effort by the Trump administration's Department of Health and Human Services -- specifically, an official with close ties to pardoned Trump confidant Roger Stone.
"Everyone did the best they could," Cuomo said when asked what he'd say to the families of those who died in nursing homes. "It's not about pointing fingers or blame. It's that this became a political football."
James has for months been examining discrepancies between the number of deaths being reported by the state's Department of Health, and the number of deaths reported by the homes themselves.
Her investigators looked at a sample of 62 of the state’s roughly 600 nursing homes. They reported 1,914 deaths of residents from COVID-19, while the state Department of Health logged only 1,229 deaths at those same facilities. One unnamed facility, for example, had an official death toll of 11 but the attorney general's probe found that 40 had actually died.
AP's analysis in August concluded that the state could be understating deaths by as much as 65%, based on discrepancies between its totals and numbers being reported to federal regulators. That analysis was, like James’ report, based on only a slice of data, rather than a comprehensive look.
To date, despite public records requests from the AP and repeated pleas from state and federal lawmakers, New York's health department has yet to produce the full number of nursing home residents who died in hospitals as well as the nursing home property.
Health Commissioner Zucker has said several times that the state is working on such data, and said in his statement Thursday that the state is still "in the midst of auditing this data from nursing homes." He added that the reporting from nursing homes is "inconsistent and often inaccurate," such as entries that list an individual as dying both in a hospital and at a nursing home, duplicate entries, or entries with missing information like an individual's name or an incorrect date of death.
State Sen. Gustavo Rivera, a Democrat who has blasted the Cuomo administration for its incomplete death count, said he was “sadly unsurprised” by the report.
“Families who lost loved ones deserve honest answers,” Rivera said. “For their sake, I hope that this report will help us unveil the truth and put policies in place to prevent such tragedies in the future.”
Cuomo, who last fall released a book touting his leadership in dealing with the virus, has not been shy about using New York's lower nursing home death count to make the argument that his state is doing better than others in caring for those in such facilities.
“There's also no doubt that we’re in this hyper-political environment so everybody wants to point fingers,” Cuomo told CBS “This Morning” in October. “New York, actually, we’re number 46 out of 50 in terms of percentage of deaths in nursing homes — 46 out of 50. So, yes, people died in nursing homes. ... but 46 out of 50, it’s not a predominantly New York problem.”
The attorney general’s report also took aim at New York's controversial March 25 policy that sought to create more space in hospitals by releasing recovering COVID-19 patients into nursing homes, which critics contended was a driving factor in causing nursing home outbreaks.
James’ report said those admissions “may have contributed to increased risk of nursing home resident infection and subsequent fatalities,” noting that at least 4,000 nursing home residents with COVID-19 died after that guidance. But James' report said the issue would require further study to conclusively prove such a link.
New York's health department released a much-criticized report last summer that claimed the March 25 policy, which was reversed in May, was “not a significant factor” in deaths. The department doubled down on their report Thursday, stating that the attorney general's report found no evidence that the March memo contributed to additional deaths at nursing homes.
James' review also found that a lack of infection controls at nursing homes put residents at increased risk of harm, while nursing homes that had lower federal scores for staffing had higher COVID-19 fatality rates. The DOH emphasized this finding, stating that the facilities failed to comply with state protocols and violated executive orders, such as the one requiring the nursing homes to inform families "in real time" when there was a COVID-19 infection or death at the facility.
“As the pandemic and our investigations continue," James wrote, “it is imperative that we understand why the residents of nursing homes in New York unnecessarily suffered at such an alarming rate.”