2012 Elections: News, Analysis, Videos, and Breaking on the Presidential Election, Local Elections, and More

2012 Elections: News, Analysis, Videos, and Breaking on the Presidential Election, Local Elections, and More

Complete coverage of the 2012 election

Analysis: Bill Clinton and the Ex-President Conundrum

The man from Hope is now Obama's chief messenger of hope that the economy well get better under Obama in a second term, and that trusting the Republicans again is a mistake.

By MICHAEL ORESKES
|  Wednesday, Sep 5, 2012  |  Updated 7:49 AM CDT
View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print
Obama, Biden & Faces of the DNC

FILE-AP

In this Dec. 10, 2010 file photo, President Barack Obama listens as former President Bill Clinton speaks in the briefing room of the White House in Washington. Clinton headlines the second day of the Democratic National Convention.

Photos and Videos
More Photos and Videos

Every political party has had leaders it would like to exalt and leaders it would like to forget. Bill Clinton has managed to be both. He is the closest thing American politics has to a rock star, and he has sometimes behaved like one.

Luckily for President Barack Obama, Clinton today is about as popular as a political figure can be. And he is popular with exactly the voters that Obama and the rest of the Democratic Party have a hard time reaching — which is to say, white people. That is why even though they haven't always been close, Obama invited Clinton to nominate him in prime time Wednesday evening, the first former president to do that.

For full election 2012 coverage visit NBCNews.com.

It is an extraordinary moment in the annals of presidential politics. Ex-presidents are sometimes useful for shows of party unity or reminders of good times. Nixon did convince Eisenhower to endorse him just before the contentious 1968 convention, recalled Michael Beschloss, the presidential historian. But like the old soldier that Ike was, most ex-presidents have generally faded away.

They don't want me around, Harry S. Truman once said. Al Gore wouldn't take Bill Clinton's help in 2000, which in retrospect looks like a big mistake. Jimmy Carter has been described as the nation's best ex-president, but he won't be a big factor in the Obama campaign because his 1980 defeat by Ronald Reagan is too reminiscent of the present economic and political dynamic. And George W. Bush was nowhere to be seen at his party convention last week.

"After the White House," said Franklin Pierce, the 14th president, "what is there to do but drink?"

But it isn't history Obama is trying to change by bringing in Clinton. It is votes. White votes. White guy votes in particular.

___

THE NUMBERS TELL a story. President Obama was viewed favorably by 43 percent of white men in an AP-GfK poll last month. It is a key reason this race is so close. Overall, Romney beat Obama 54 to 39 percent among white voters in that poll.

White voters make up a bit more than 70 percent of the electorate in recent presidential years, according to exit polls. Obama doesn't have to win among white voters to win the election. Most Democrats don't carry the white vote. But he does have to keep Romney from building up such a lead that he can't make up the difference by winning among blacks, Hispanics and perhaps even women.

Enter Clinton, who, at a year older than Romney, can't really be the Comeback Kid anymore. But 12 years out of office, he is viewed favorably by 63 percent of white men, according to a Gallup Poll in July.

He took his party and his country on a roller-coaster ride, from Gennifer Flowers through impeachment. But looking back now, folks don't see scandal, said Richard Harpootlian, they see what happens to the economy when you give a Democratic president two terms.

Harpootlian is a Democrat from South Carolina, a place where, like Arkansas, being a Democrat takes a special skill. "He resonates with Southern white folks dramatically," Harpootlian says. "What they want to know is who is going to put groceries and grits on the table."

Turns out, that is what the whole country wants to know now. Well, maybe not the grits part.

Clinton, the man from Hope, is now Obama's chief messenger of hope that the economy well get better under Obama in a second term, as it did under Clinton, and that trusting the Republicans again is a mistake.

But Clinton is more than just an economic messenger. Or, more exactly, his economic message is effective because he has a visceral connection to white voters, particularly white guys. "We see ourselves in him," said Gus Mansour, a 54-year-old delegate from Lynwood, Wash.

Victor Rawls, a South Carolina delegate, explains it this way: "Do I have a connection with Bill Clinton? Bill Clinton has a little bit of a narcissistic string to him. I understand that. Bill Clinton is a very intelligent man and he's also ... able to communicate across a lot of levels. It's really bizarre that a Democratic president is able to maintain contact with the Fortune 500 companies like he has. No other Democratic president that I'm aware of in history has been able to do that."

___

CLINTON AND OBAMA are strikingly opposite characters. "Bill Clinton is effusive," says Harpootlian, who has worked with both men. "He's a hugger. He's got an amazing memory for people names and places. He's got a Rolodex in his head, more in the mold of a southern politician — 'Hail, fellow, well met' but with a huge intellect. Barack on the other hand is cool, almost like hip cool, he walks into a room he radiates this Frank Sinatra coolness. You can't not sense him. It's infectious."

Obama is disciplined and cerebral; Clinton is, well, not.

That, says Josh Lockman, may be part of his appeal. As a millennial voter, Lockman, 30 and from Los Angeles, sees the Obama campaign, which he has worked with, as cold-eyed and focused on statistical analysis of voting patterns and microtargeting of constituencies.

"His campaign has taken almost a mathematical systematic statistical approach to appealing to key voting groups," Lockman said, "whether Latino Americans with immigration or young Americans with student loans or Jewish Americans on Israel and Iran."

That may be a winning strategy, he said, but it isn't always an inspiring one.

Clinton is often said to have the best political mind in the business. Obama's invite was in itself a kind of microtargeting at the biggest niche of voters, white guys. But Clinton's real strength is his ability to soar above the mechanics of politics, Lockman says, "dispensing with the microtargeting statistical approach and emphasizing the humanistic one."

Clinton is nothing if not human. One risk the Obama campaign is accepting is that Clinton will run over his time Wednesday night. It's more than possible, of course. This will be Clinton's seventh convention speech, and he has logged a total of nearly four hours at the rostrum. Nobody is certain precisely how many hours he was actually supposed to log.

Clinton has his own motives for delivering Wednesday evening. They're part of who he has always been. "Throughout his political career he was focused, some might say obsessed, with reweaving the coalition between minority voters and the white working class," said his former speechwriter, Michael Waldman. "He thought of it as repairing what was broken after Robert Kennedy's murder. He argued passionately that if Democrats talked about the shared values of opportunity, responsibility and community, they could win the votes of both inner-city blacks and suburban Reagan Democrats."

There is only one other recent ex-president who remains such a potent force in his party. He is to Republicans what Clinton is to Democrats. He redefined the party and reached toward the middle. He pulled in voters that his party needed. That's why, today, they call them Reagan Democrats.

Ronald Reagan, dead eight years, still managed to be a featured speaker at the Republican National Convention last week, appearing relentlessly in video after video. Mitt Romney sought to cloak himself in Reagan, to bask in the rays of an absent legend.

But when Barack Obama turns to his own party's political idol, he won't have to rely on digital smoke and big-screen mirrors. No tech will be required. The legend, Bill Clinton, will be standing right next to him.

Get the latest headlines sent to your inbox!
View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print
Leave Comments
What's New
Get Our Weather App
Stay ahead of the storm with the NBC... Read more
Follow Us
Sign up to receive news and updates that matter to you.
Send Us Your Story Tips
Check Out