Black Texas Inmate Seems Likely to Win at Supreme Court - NBC Chicago
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

Black Texas Inmate Seems Likely to Win at Supreme Court

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Black Texas Inmate Seems Likely to Win at Supreme Court
    TX Dept. of Correction/NBC 5 News
    Duane Buck was condemned for the July 1995 slaying of his ex-girlfriend and a man at her Houston apartment.

    The Supreme Court left little doubt Wednesday that it will side with a black Texas prison inmate who argues improper testimony about his race tainted his death sentence.

    The justices often are divided on death penalty cases, but conservatives and liberals alike agreed that inmate Duane Buck is entitled to a new court hearing.

    The only issue in arguments at the high court appeared to be whether to throw out Buck's sentence altogether and order a new punishment hearing. The court also could merely instruct lower courts to decide whether the death sentence can stand.

    Buck has been trying for years to get federal courts to look at his claim that his rights were violated when jurors were told by a defense expert witness that Buck was more likely to be dangerous in the future because he is black.

    Drew Angerer/Getty Images

    In Texas death penalty trials, one of the "special issues" jurors must consider when deciding punishment is whether the defendant they've convicted would be a future danger.

    "What occurred at the penalty phase is indefensible," Justice Samuel Alito said in a comment that was widely shared by the six other justices who asked questions Wednesday. Justice Clarence Thomas asked no questions, as is his custom.

    The high court appeal is not a broad challenge to the death penalty in Texas, the nation's leader by far in carrying out 537 executions since the Supreme Court in 1976 allowed capital punishment to resume. Rather, it shows the justices' heightened attention to the process in capital cases, from sentencing to execution. This is especially true in older cases, like Buck's, in which the quality of defense lawyers is at issue.

    The New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals refused attempts by Buck's attorneys to reopen the case, blocking them from moving forward with an appeal contending Buck's constitutional right to a competent lawyer was violated.

    Buck's case was among six in 2000 that then-Texas Attorney General John Cornyn in a news release said needed to be reopened because statements by the expert witness, Dr. Walter Quijano, were racially charged. In the other five cases, new punishment hearings were held and each convict again was sentenced to death. Cornyn, a Republican, is now the state's senior U.S. senator.

    Buck's lawyers contended the attorney general, by then Cornyn's successor Greg Abbott, broke a promise by contesting his case, although the 5th Circuit said while that circumstance was "odd and factually unusual," they could find nothing in the case record to indicate the state made an error or promised not to oppose any move to reopen the case. Abbott now is the state's governor.

    Vandals Disrupt St. Louis Businesses After Protest

    [NATL] Dozens Arrested After St. Louis Businesses Were Vandalized, Police Say

    Police in St. Louis arrested more than 80 people and confiscated at least five weapons after violence broke out following peaceful protests, the police chief said Monday.

    "People setting out to do damage are being arrested, and these criminals we've arrested should be held accountable and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law," said Acting Police Commissioner Lawrence O'Toole during a press conference early Monday morning. "We're in control, this is our city and we are going to protect it."

    The protests are in response to a recent not guilty verdict for an ex-police officer who was charged with first-degree murder.

     

    (Published Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017)

    Texas Solicitor General Scott Keller defended the appellate ruling Wednesday because he said there is ample evidence to support a death sentence.

    Buck, now 53, does not dispute that he shot and killed his ex-girlfriend, Debra Gardner, 32, about a week after breaking up with her, and another man in 1995. He also shot his stepsister, who survived.

    Buck at the time was on parole after serving about a year of a 10-year prison term for delivery of cocaine. He also had a previous conviction for unlawfully carrying a weapon.

    'Rocket Man': Trump Slams N. Korea at UN

    [NATL] 'Rocket Man': Trump Slams North Korea in First Address to UN

    On his first address to the United Nation's General Assembly, President Donald Trump called for more countries to join together against North Korea and Iran, and for Venezuela to restore "democracy and political freedoms." 

    (Published Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017)

    Still, no justice appeared to endorse Keller's argument that the appellate ruling should be upheld.

    Christina Swarns, Buck's lawyer at the Supreme Court, sought at one point to place Buck's case in the broader context of issues of race in the criminal justice system, telling the justices that the need to eradicate racial prejudice "is as urgent today as at any time in our nation's history."

    The debate at the court was mostly over how the justices might rule in Buck's favor.

    Hurricane Maria Batters Guadeloupe

    [NATL] Hurricane Maria Batters Guadeloupe

    Hurricane Maria swept over Guadeloupe and other parts of the Caribbean early Tuesday as it approached the U.S. Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico. Guadeloupe's Pointe-a-Pitre airport, as well as its capital, Basse-Terre, were battered with heavy wind and rain as Maria moved over the French territory. 

    (Published Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017)

    The justices could decide there was a "constitutional violation in this case and the court of appeals was wrong to say there wasn't," Chief Justice John Roberts said. Such a ruling would result in a new sentencing hearing for Buck.

    Justice Elena Kagan said a decision instead could focus on the appeals court's approach to inmates who wish to reopen their cases in unusual circumstances, which would leave the decision on the death sentence to a lower court. Such a ruling might affect other inmates in the three states covered by the 5th Circuit — Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas.

    Kagan cited figures produced by Buck's lawyers that prisoners in the 5th Circuit are far less likely to be allowed to pursue their appeals than prisoners in other Southern states.

    Hurricane Maria Churns Toward Caribbean

    [NATL] Hurricane Maria Churns Toward Caribbean, Threatens Puerto Rico

    Authorities have issued a hurricane watch for Puerto Rico as Hurricane Maria churns toward the Eastern Caribbean amid forecasts it could become a major hurricane.

    (Published Monday, Sept. 18, 2017)