Man Who Threw Fatal Punch at Beach Party Ordered Back to Jail

Judge said James Malecek, convicted of involuntary manslaughter in the death of 17-year-old Kevin Kennelly, violated his sentencing agreement

The man convicted of involuntary manslaughter in the 2011 death of a Chicago teenager in Long Beach, Indiana, was ordered back to jail Friday for 40 days for violating his sentencing agreement.

A judge said James Malecek repeatedly violated his G.P.S. monitoring agreement and even attended a Cubs game with his girlfriend in April, posting pictures on Facebook.

Malecek was immediately handcuffed in the courtroom and led back to the same LaPorte County jail where he spent three months last summer as part of his sentence for killing Mt. Carmel High School student Kevin Kennelly with one punch during an alcohol-fueled July 4th skirmish.

Malecek "was given a chance, and he violated that and should suffer the consequences," prosecutor Rob Neery told the judge.

A letter from the company assigned to keep track of Malecek cited him earlier this year for attending a birthday party for a friend "at, or near the Chase Tower" in Chicago on April 11 where alcohol was served, in violation of his sentencing agreement.

"We weren't looking to have him retried for his crime," Kennelly's father, Kevin, said. "It was just to have the sentence enforced that was passed down last May of 2013."

During the July 4th weekend in 2011, Kennelly and several friends became involved in an alcohol-fueled altercation with another group of teenagers at a beach in Long Beach, Ind. One was Malecek, who had just graduated from Loyola Academy in north suburban Wilmette.

During the altercation Malecek threw one swift "sucker punch" -- as the local police chief later described it -- killing Kennelly.

Malecek was ultimately convicted of involuntary manslaughter nearly two years later, in May of 2013 - just four days before he turned 21 years old.

He was sentenced by La Porte County Circuit Court Judge Thomas Alevizos to three months in the county jail, followed by almost four years of strict G.P.S. monitoring or, as one law enforcement expert calls it, "prison without the jail cell."

The court order stipulated that Malecek adhere to a nightly curfew of 8 p.m. and it allowed him to go only to his job and to attend classes and related activities at DePaul University.

At the time of the sentencing the judge told Malecek he was being given a "gift," adding that the sentence "could have been much worse." The judge advised him to do something with his life "for the greater good."

After the 40 days in jail, Malecek will again be placed on electronic monitoring.

Contact Us