ComEd Competition: Will You Save Money?

There are now a half-dozen energy companies on the Chicago landscape offering electric service to residential customers

By Kim Vatis
|  Friday, Mar 18, 2011  |  Updated 7:56 PM CDT
View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print
There are a half dozen energy companies new to the <a title=Chicago landscape beginning to offer electric service to residential customers." />

There are a half dozen energy companies new to the Chicago landscape beginning to offer electric service to residential customers.

Photos and Videos

CPA: Don't Cheat Yourself Out of Tax Refund Money

CPA Barry Steiner says a lot of people could get more back by itemizing their deductions.

5 Habits of Financially Successful People

Wealthier people seem to avoid the pitfalls and plan their wealth strategies, acknowledging that reckless spending can derail savings plans.
More Photos and Videos

Deregulation in the energy industry opened the doors to competition back in 1997, but the market is only recently beginning to light up.

There are now a half-dozen energy companies on the Chicago landscape offering electric service to residential customers, some offering discounts up to 30 percent lower than ComEd's prices, and their pitches are strong.

But while switching can take just minutes, it doesn't come without warning.

"This is something people are not used to shopping for," said Citizen Utility Board Executive Director David Kolata.  "We've had situations that what you think you are signing up for you are not signing up for, so you want to make sure you are an educated consumer."

Right now, the rates vary nearly 30 percent, from ComEds high of 8.3 cents per kilowatt hour to Champion’s low 6.4 cents.  Bluestar of Chicago, Constellation, Direct Energy, Energy Plus, Ambit Energy, Nordic Energy and Spark Energy fall in between.

Contracts go from monthly to yearly, but if you’re dissatisfied and want out, early termination fees could be as high as $150.  Each deal is different, and customers should make sure they get any offer in writing.

"This could be an opportunity to save money," said Kolata, but there are no guarantees.

Another caveat:  two big factors could soon change the competitive landscape. 

ComEd is expected to reduce its electric rates this June, but at the same time is expected to hike up its delivery rates if it gets approval from the Illinois Commerce Commission next month.

The average delivery rate increase would be seven percent.  That's important because even if you switch to another power provider, you cannot escape that part of ComEd’s rates.  No matter what company supplies the energy, Comed will be delivering it to your home.

"So if a company says, 'This is a way to avoid ComEd rate increases,' that is not true," advised Kolata.

In a statement, ComEd said it has been a "champion and advocate for competition," and supports the right of the consumer to choose their energy supplier.

The CUB has put together a fact sheet on all the companies in the marketplace comparing rates and terms of the contracts.  Another website, Power2Switch, is offering one-stop shopping for resources and easy switching to at least some of the companies.  PluginIllinois also has offers and comparison tips.

But will the switch save you money?

"I think the jury is still out if residential competition is going to have lasting value for consumers," said Kolata.

The concern is that while consumers have the opportunity to save money with competitive pricing now, many will let the switch burn a hole in their pocket later.

Deregulation in the natural gas market also brought a bevy of competitors, but in the end 93 percent actually ended up spending an average of $700 more per year.

"We hope the electric market is different," said Kolata.

So far, residential switch rates have been low.

$mart Money: Navigating the Road to Financial Freedom

Get the latest headlines sent to your inbox!
View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print
Leave Comments
What's New
Get Our Weather App
Stay ahead of the storm with the NBC 5... Read more
Follow Us
Sign up to receive news and updates that matter to you.
Send Us Your Story Tips
Check Out